• Our Sponsors

    Skype

Counter-Intuitiveness Comes of Age

Published Nov 03 2008 Updated Nov 02 2008

Penelope Trunk’s Brazen Careerist: The New Rules for Success is one of the rare career books that is often counter-intuitive in its guidance yet stays with you a little longer than expected. I was both amused and engaged by chapters entitled “Be a Sponge,” or “Assume the Job Description Was Wrong” or “When Writing Your Resume, Don’t Be Too Honest.”

A former professional beach volleyball player, software executive and IPO survivor, Trunk reinvented herself a few years ago as an author, blogger and career columnist for Yahoo! Finance and the Boston Globe (The Climb).

It’s not so much that Trunk advocates lying on your resume, what she preaches is closer to spin control, though she doesn’t call it that. “If you’re too honest you sound like a psychopath,” she says. After all, a resume is “not a list of every truth in your life. In my mind it’s absurd that people give advice that says ‘Don’t lie on your resume’ because it’s totally useless advice. ”

The trick she explains is “knowing how to frame your life in a way that is informative but not lying.” For instance, Trunk says she dropped out of a graduate school English program to take a job managing a website for a Fortune 500 company. “It would be ludicrous to put in my resume that I left to pursue a lot of money instead of taking out more Stafford loans,” she says. In her resume, she doesn’t claim to have graduated from the English program, just that she attended.

Trunk makes sharply observed points about changes in the workplace and what this means for job seekers and hiring managers. She is at her most salient when she contrasts and compares generational changes between what the “millennials” want versus the Gen X and Gen Y and Baby Boomers before them. “The workplace divide is no longer between men and women it’s between older and younger people,” she says. “Now it’s young people valuing time vs. older people valuing money.”

The Gen-Ys and Millennials don’t want to climb corporate ladders any more than they want to work sixty hour weeks, says Trunk. Instead they want mentors, time-off and personal development – and many of them are smart enough to negotiate for it right out of college. Seeking more responsibility doesn’t hold the same appeal to the new generations. “Getting promoted is moving along on someone else’s path,” says Trunk. “Young people are all about personalization and customization and generally it’s not going to be a step someone else has laid out for them.”

Getting ahead, says Trunk, entails more emotional intelligence than anything else. “Being likeable matters more than being competent,” she contends. She argues this is, in a way, a good thing. “The idea that we value skills first is tragic and it has lead to backstabbing, hurtfulness and workplaces that don’t care about personal lives.”

Trunk, who enjoys saying things “straight,” strongly advises budding careerists to specialize rather than become generalists. In this sense Trunk’s advice is somewhat akin to the popular concept of personal branding, which she calls typecasting. “People with power need to see you as someone who is extremely good at something, and no one is extremely good at everything, so don’t sell yourself that way to senior managers.” Good point. Although Trunk would be among the first to admit that if one career path isn’t working for you there’s always another worth taking.

Join The Discussion

  1. good post, i read the book and its great

  2. I like what she writes and it all makes good sense. We are developing new questions to probe Millennial motivation because that is so key to good hiring decisions.

  3. well, the GenX/Y/Millenials are just learning from what the Baby Boomers started. One of my published articles goes over “the 5 gifts from the Baby Boomers”

    ~ Vikram
    PersonalBrandMarketing.com

  4. Comment 04 on Counter-Intuitiveness Comes of Age
    Adina
    Thursday, Dec 25, 2008 at 12:27am

    I think she’s right, in general terms. But I disagree with her statement that no one is extremely good at everything. (well, not “everything,” but there definitely are people who are extremely good at many things).

    I think it is comfortable for some of us to assume that an individual can only do one very narrow type of activity very well. This may be true for some people, no doubt. It might make us feel “safe” to see a specialist, because after all, that is the only thing the guy does – he better do it right, right?
    But there is also an ugly side of specialization. Specialization means that we have to pay more to have our problems resolved. That is because instead of being able to go to one doctor who could address all of your 3 symptoms, today you need to go to three doctors, each time paying your deductible, taking time off work, etc. Also, a specialist is likely to charge more for his services, because he is a “specialist.”

    In rare case, specialization may be necessary. But I think in general, it is foolish for society to move toward more and more specialization. I personally am thankful for the “holistic” movement, rather than the “overspecialization” movement.

    Also, what happens to the overspecialized person when there is no need for his specialty anymore? How can he ever learn anything else, since he can do only one thing right?

    The truth is, that the same skills (such as problem solving ability, etc.) can be applied to many different areas of knowledge and activity. It is also wrong to try to pigeon hole people who may have much broader talents and abilities than we can understand.

Leave a Reply

  • Career Resources

    Check out our first list of useful blogs, career tools and social media sites for job seekers and global careerists. With your suggestions, we will add many more resources.
  • Global Virtual Management

    Want to become an expert at "virtual" business management? Check out our free, self-guided Career Primer by Colleen Garton, author of Managing Without Walls.
  • LET’S STAY IN TOUCH

    Want to sign up for our contact list? Choices include: newsletter, job seekers and career advice. We respect your privacy.